Risk and exits

What Should I Do After a Big Losing Day?

The hours after a large loss are when a second one is easiest to set up. A fixed procedure takes the decisions out of your hands while your judgment is at its worst.

Short answer

Stop trading for the rest of the session, then check every open position and working order. Write down what happened while you still remember it, sort each loss into a rule break or a loss taken within your rules, and trade smaller the next session.

It is early afternoon, the account is down by more than you have let it fall in a single day before, and the strongest urge in the room is to find one good trade that makes it back before the close.

Close the order ticket.

What follows is a procedure. It is short on purpose, because you are going to follow it on a day when you would rather do something else, and every step is something you can do without having to judge the market.

The procedure

  1. Stop trading for the session. No new entries, including the one that looks obvious. Log out of the trading screen if that helps.
  2. Check every open position and working order. Stops, limit orders, good-til-canceled orders left from earlier in the week, bracket legs left behind after you closed a position by hand. Cancel anything you no longer mean. Anything you will hold overnight gets a real stop at the broker.
  3. Write down what happened, now. Tonight you will remember a tidier version.
  4. Sort each losing trade. Did you follow your rules and lose anyway, or did you break one?
  5. Set the size for the next session. Smaller than normal, for example half, decided today.
  6. Decide what earns normal size back. A number of sessions traded within the rules, chosen now.

Step 2 comes before the write-up for a reason. Your write-up can wait an hour. An orphaned stop order on a position you already closed can open a new one without you.

Writing it down

For each trade record the entry, the exit, the share count, the planned stop, the reason for the trade in one line and what you actually did. Times help. So does a note on what you were feeling, in plain words, since the same state tends to show up before the same mistakes.

Keep it factual. The page is for the version of you who reads it next month and needs to see exactly where the day turned, which is hard to reconstruct once the details have faded into a general sense that everything went wrong at once.

Rule breaks and bad luck

Here is a hypothetical day with four losing trades, sorted.

Trade What happened Rules followed?
1 Stopped out at the planned level, normal size Yes: a loss within the rules
2 Entered with no written reason after trade 1 No
3 Double size to make back trades 1 and 2 No
4 Moved the stop, then sold far below it No

Trade 1 is the cost of doing business. Nothing needs fixing there, and treating it as a mistake can push you into changing a method that was working. Trades 2 to 4 are the actual problem, and they share one cause: each was an attempt to repair the loss before it.

That split tells you what to change. Losses within the rules may call for no change at all. Rule breaks call for a rule that is easier to follow, written while the market is closed.

If trade 4 involved holding past the planned exit, how long to hold a losing trade covers the two exits every trade should have.

The next session

Trade smaller. The point of the reduced size is to let you practice following the rules with a loss that does not sting, so the next day is about process and the number on the screen stays small whatever happens.

Take fewer trades as well. Logging the setups you pass on, in a skipped-trades log, gives your attention somewhere useful to go.

When to take longer off

A day off, or several, makes sense when:

  • you broke a daily loss limit you had set in advance;
  • you cannot explain, from your notes, why you took most of the trades;
  • the loss touched money you need for something else;
  • you are thinking about the market late at night and planning how to win it all back.

None of these calls for a verdict on whether you should trade at all. They call for time away from the screen until you can read your own notes calmly, followed by a return at reduced size under the rules you wrote while you were away.

Also asked

Should I set a daily loss limit?
Some traders do: a fixed amount or share of the account after which they stop for the day. Choose the figure while the market is closed and write it into your rules, so it is not decided in the moment.