Close Social Feeds Before the Open and Keep Them Closed
During the session, a feed supplies strangers' certainty at the exact moment your own decisions should come from the plan you wrote. Close it at the open and reopen it after the close.
The position Social feeds should be closed for the whole trading session, because they replace your plan with other people's conviction.
Your trading plan is the only document on your screen written by someone who knows your account. Everything else was written by strangers. Most of them want your attention, and none of them know your size, your stop or why you’re in the trade.
Close the feeds at the open. Keep them closed until the close.
The feed arrives at the worst time
A plan does its work in advance. You write the entry, the exit and the size when nothing is moving, which is the argument behind writing rules when the market is closed. During the session, your job is to carry it out.
A feed during the session pulls the other way. It supplies conviction (other people’s) at the exact moment yours should be coming from the page you wrote before the bell, and it supplies it in a steady stream, so that each time you look away from the chart you come back carrying someone else’s certainty about a stock you already had a plan for.
That’s how a stop gets moved. Someone confident says the level will hold, someone else posts a chart with a much higher target, and although the plan is exactly what it was an hour ago, your confidence in it has slipped.
What you are actually reading
Posts are selected for attention. The ones that reach you are the ones that got reactions, and reactions go to certainty, big numbers and screenshots of wins. A measured post saying a trade might work, sized small, with a stop underneath, travels less far than one saying a stock is going much higher. Of course it does.
And you can’t see the parts that matter:
- How big the poster’s position is.
- Where they got in.
- Where they will get out.
- Whether they already sold.
- Whether they hold the stock at all.
Someone who bought far below the current price can be relaxed about a drop that would stop you out. Someone with a tiny position can post a bold call at no real cost, and someone who has already sold has every reason to keep the post up. Some accounts exist to promote a stock the poster intends to sell into your buying, and from the outside, on a phone, in the middle of a fast session, a paid promotion and a sincere opinion can look exactly alike. You get the words and none of the numbers behind them.
Three ways it shows up in your trades
Mostly it shows up as small departures from the plan, each one easy to justify in the moment.
First, entries you didn’t plan. A ticker you’d never looked at is suddenly everywhere, and you buy it because everyone seems to be in it, with no stop decided and a size picked by feel.
Then exits you didn’t plan. A position you were comfortable with gets sold because a post called the company a fraud, or held past its stop because a post said the dip was a gift.
And simply more trades. Each post is a small prompt to act. More prompts mean more orders, and each order is another spread paid and another decision made in a hurry.
One test covers all three. Take any trade from today and ask whether it, with its entry, stop and size, could have been written down before the open from what you knew then. If it couldn’t, and you can trace it to something you read during the session, the feed made that trade and your plan didn’t.
Check a week of trades that way. It’s a quick review, done from your own order history, and it can be uncomfortable.
A schedule that works
Research stays. It moves to the hours when nothing is trading.
| When | What | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Evening or before the open | Read, research, scroll if you want | Ideas become plans while nothing is moving |
| Before the open | Check a calendar for scheduled events | Earnings, economic releases and company events are known in advance |
| During the session | Charts, orders, one timestamped news source | Execution only |
| After the close | Feeds back on, if you want them | Review with the day’s result already fixed |
The scheduled-events check matters more than it looks. Much of what moves a stock on a given day, such as an earnings report or a scheduled economic release, is announced in advance and sits on a calendar, so a few minutes before the open covers a large part of what you’d otherwise hope to catch in a feed.
Then close the tabs. Log out of the apps on the device you trade from, or put them on another device entirely. Relying on willpower to ignore an open app is asking a lot of yourself in the middle of a session, and putting the app out of reach asks much less.
The strongest objection: breaking news
Real news does break during the session. A halt, a guidance cut, an acquisition, a regulatory decision. Missing it can cost money, and shutting everything off means you’d miss it.
That’s a case for a news source, and a fair one. Use a feed that carries headlines with timestamps, from outlets that report news, and keep it to that. A timestamp lets you check whether the headline is new or an hour old and already priced. A news headline also tells you what happened, where a post tells you how someone feels about it, and the feelings are the part to cut.
Where the rule bends
If your strategy is built around reacting to news within seconds, you need a faster information source than most, and you should treat it as a professional tool with rules of its own. That’s a narrow group.
For everyone else, the session is for running the plan. If the feed has already done damage, and you traded a post and lost on it, what to do after a big losing day is the place to start. The same logic sits behind choosing to hide the dollar P&L during the session: remove what pulls your attention off the plan while the plan is running.
Also asked
- What about chat rooms with other traders?
- The same reasoning applies. A room full of live calls is a feed with faster posts, and you still can't see anyone's size, entry or exit.